Best Pizza in Oakhurst

LEFT OVERS ARE FOR QUITTERS

Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Memphis Hot Salad

Romaine, cornbread crumble, dill pickle, crispy chicken, hot ranch

Add Item

The Oakhurst Sandwich

Fried eggplant, vodka sauce, burrata, oak hill farms honey

Add Item

Bellmore Sandwich

Grilled chicken, blistered tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pickled red onion, pesto aioli

Add Item

Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, roasted chickpeas, parmesan crisp, toasted breadcrumb, housemade caesar

Add Item

Buffalo Wrap

Chicken cutlet, house made buffalo, chopped pickle, romaine, pickled red onion, hot ranch

Add Item

Oakhurst

Breaded eggplant, vodka sauce, burrata, Oak Hill Farms Hot Honey. Served with fresh pasta made by Semolina Pasta Shoppe.

Add Item

Pesto Entree

Fusilli, broccoli pesto, roasted red pepper, cream toasted bread crumb, lemon zest. Served with fresh pasta made by Semolina Pasta Shoppe.

Add Item

Vodka Pizza

Add Item

Tommy Pickles (Large)

Pickle, bacon, breadcrumb, dill-ranch

Add Item

The Millie (Large)

Fried eggplant, mushroom, pepper, onion, broccoli

Add Item

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Now

Welcome to PEEL

📌 Located at 2001 Bellmore St Ste B in Oakhurst, NJ, PEEL is your local spot for one-of-a-kind pizza and dishes. Whether you're in the mood to sit down and enjoy a casual meal, grab a quick slice, or plan an event, we’ve got you covered. We love welcoming our community, and there's always room at the table for you.

Catering & Private Events

Planning a special gathering? Let PEEL handle the food! Whether it’s a birthday, family get-together, or work event, our catering services are here to make things easy and delicious. We offer a variety of pizza options and other unique dishes that are perfect for sharing with your guests. From small gatherings to big celebrations, we’ve got the food covered so you can focus on the fun.

Catering & Private Events Form

Order Online – It's Easy!

Life’s busy, and we get that. Ordering from PEEL is as easy as a few taps on your phone. Whether you’re craving pizza for dinner or want to skip cooking altogether, you can count on us for fast and convenient delivery or pickup.

Order On Slice

Bold Pizzas, Fresh Flavors – Always Ready For A Slice Of Life

Here’s a sneak peek of the items our customers can’t stop talking about

Grab a Slice or Stay Awhile

Whether you’re in a rush or want to sit back and relax, we’re ready for you. Swing by for a quick slice during your lunch break, or stay for a full meal with friends and family. We’ve designed our space to be comfortable and inviting, so you’ll feel right at home. Hosting an event? PEEL is the perfect spot to make it special.

Join Us!

At PEEL, we’re proud to be part of the Oakhurst community. We love seeing familiar faces and welcoming new ones, too. Whether you’re here to grab a quick meal or planning to host a fun event, we’re excited to make every visit special. So come by, order online, or give us a call – we’re here for you. Come Visit Us! 📌 2001 Bellmore St Ste B, Oakhurst, NJ 07755, United States

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

First off, solid slice pie selection. Classics and gourmets all looked great. Chicken parm slice and white slice were both super good. The sauce is top tier unquestionably. Friendly folks, great food, cant wait til next time.

Gerald A.

A gem of a restaurant and a breath of fresh air compared to your standard Jersey spots. Their Sunday sauce is comparable to your grandmas (they’re family owned/ran and you can tell- their food is cooked with love). Their pizza and Buffalo chicken sliders are some of the best in this entire area. Restaurant is clean, cute, and family friendly. 10/10 on all of their many menu items we tried, we’ll be back to try the rest!

Sarah W.

We live in the local neighborhood and just tried Peel for the first time. What an awesome experience! As soon as I walked in and saw the pies in the case, I knew we were in for a good mea. We loved the pizzas, the prices are on point, they served up a terrific strawberry & arugula salad, and they have a great mix of traditional and innovative menu items. What a welcome addition to the local food scene.